Saturday, November 03, 2007

Jeb backed driver’s licenses for the undocumented

Not often in agreement with our former governor, I found myself nodding positively through Beth Reinhard’s column in the Saturday Miami Herald. The other day I was mentally arguing against “Big Ed” Schultz on normally reliable Air America, WINZ AM940, as he raved against letting undocumented immigrants have licenses.

Schultz’ argument was that immigrants “take jobs” from American workers (Evidence, Ed?) and “drive down” wages (Maybe true), and so “80 percent” of Americans are against letting such immigrants have licenses. Ed, I’d like to hear what wording was used in the survey to get that overwhelming result. Maybe this: Should illegal aliens be given driver’s licenses so they can run down your grandmother?

Because I also have heard that Americans in general feel that immigrants should get a path to legalization and eventual citizenship, and it would seem contradictory that they not also get a driver’s license along the way.

My life experience includes living overseas a lot, and I’ve had driver’s licenses from Israel, Britain, Japan and Germany – as a legal resident, of course. Seems pretty routine to me – you live somewhere, you get a driver’s license there. If you get stopped it’s one less problem. It’s also part of living openly.

Reinhard’s column recalls that three years ago Jeb Bush supported a bill by a fellow Republican, Sen. Rudy Garcia of Hialeah, requiring background checks before granting such licenses. It failed utterly with other Republicans and did not become law.

Now it’s a fuss in New York with Gov. Elliot Spitzer’s proposal and Hillary Clinton’s wavering reply in this week’s Democratic presidential debate.

From neo-con paradise (The Hoover Institute) emerges a quote from Jeb: “Politicians use this as a wedge issue – it’s a loser.”

Again, I agree with Jeb on this. Thanks to Beth Reinhard for laying it out. Click here for a link to her column.

3 comments:

RightDemocrat said...

Jeb and Hillary are wrong and proof of how out of the elites of both parites have become on this issue. We need to enforce our immigration laws and protect American jobs. Illegal immigration lowers wages - it's a matter of supply and demand - and the poorest American workers (often African American or Hispanic) get hurt.

Public opinion on a national level is strongly against driver's licenses for illegals. In South Florida, the vast majority of immigrants are legal rather than illegal. Miami-Dade isn't LA so I don't see a big constituency demanding driver licenses for illegals.

Anonymous said...

There is no need to make an argument on whether illegal immigrants take jobs or lower wages.

WHY CAN'T WE JUST ENFORCE OUR LAWS?

This has nothing to do with being anti-immigrant.

I'm anti the state/federal gvmt. not doing what its supposed to do.

I read somewhere that supporting these plans is good because it would "force" illegals to obtain insurance thereby lowering the number of hit and runs and lowering the overall insurance rates.

Just in case you all didnt know, most (IF NOT ALL) insurance companies require a SSN. So since these drivers are here ILLEGALLY, how on earth will they obtain insurance ?

Also, insofar as living over seas. What country allows you to drive while in their borders illegally?

Anonymous said...

You have a dream of possessing a dashing brand new car or have the idea of opening your transport business. But sudden bankruptcy ruptures all of your desires. You are damn desperate to fulfill your dream but none of lenders are ready to bet on you. At this situation, auto loans for bankruptcy are available and are ready to supervise you, in your financial ground. These types of loans are not only for financial help but can increase your credit in the financial market.To find online car loans, quick car loans visit http://www.driversamerica.com